Celtic Cultural Psychotherapy
Spirit, Place: a Reviving Celtic Shamanism
by Alastair McIntosh
published in The Trumpeter – Journal of Ecosophy, 13:3, Summer 1996, Victoria,
Canada, pp. 111-120. This paper stands alone, but follows on from “Over
the Rainbow – An Irish Pilgrimage” published by the same journal in
1994 (11:3, pp. 131-135).
It is said that the close study of stone will reveal traces of fires
suffered thousands of years ago.... I am beginning to believe that we know
everything, that all history, including the history of each family, is part of
us, such that, when we hear any secret revealed our lives are made suddenly
clearer to us.... Perhaps we are like stones; our own history and the history
of the world is embedded in us, we hold a sorrow deep within and cannot weep
until that history is sung.
Susan Griffin, a Chorus of Stones: The Private Life of War.1
grew up ten miles from the Callanish Stones on Lewis in the Outer Hebrides,
off the north-west of Scotland. To most of us then, the Stones were nothing
special. They were a place to take visitors; a place to get cold while
standing around as they took pictures. Others may have felt some magic, but I
never did, nor any local person known to me as a boy. In those days most of
the upper part of the village was comprised of thatched stone "black
houses." I remember then, in the early sixties, thinking that this was
the most important part to set in my mind because it would soon be gone. It
has now been gone, since about 1970, which in my perception was the time when
the modern world became most fully triumphant in these western edges of the
Old World; the time when, for instance, we lost our coastline fisheries to
technology, greed and global economics ... the period when those siblings of
earlier generations who had gone forth from our soil to the great New World
landed on the moon ... but that is another story. This one is mainly about
the nineteenth century, Lady Matheson, proprietor of Lewis, cleaned up the
site at Callanish because the stones were being used as a public convenience
by the villagers. Apparently this caused quite a fuss, removing as it did the
only amenity value the Stones had. There was no inkling of any religious
significance, though I do know a modern day wicca woman resident on Lewis
who says that, until her recent death there was an old woman living by the
Stones who did know some of their secrets; feeling too their connection with
the "Sleeping Beauty" mountain to the South, under the Ben Mhor by
the awesome Loch Seaforth.
I was back at Callanish in early May this year with a group of students on their Human Ecology field trip. John MacGregor was with us; a wise man, a Harris Tweed weaver who was born in a black house in the nearby Tolstachaolais village. As the students variously admired, photographed, hugged and shrugged off the stones, I asked John if he thought they had any special significance.
cannot tell what they meant in the past," he concurred, "though the
old people believed they had to do with marking the death of significant
persons in the community." But nevertheless, he did feel they had a
power; "a power which could be for both good and evil." He had his
reasons for such views. And because John is no fool, I wondered if maybe I too
should permit a greater degree of respect without, of course, sailing too
close to the will-o'-the-wisp spirituality of caricatured New-Ageism.
so to Ireland. I was to present a paper on Celtic shamanism as a mode of
social and environmental activism. I had in mind the way in which the
ecumenical Iona Community has recovered a contemporary Celtic Christianity.
The Community recognised that historical records, such as Adamnan's biography
of the missionary saint, Columba, offered little insight of practical modern
use. Really, these fragmentary sources could only be of curiosity value and
provide speculative inspiration. The real spiritual work had be grounded in
the context of people's lives today, not in those of A.D. 563 when Columba
came from Ireland to Scotland. Such contemporary contextualisation is where
the "movement of the Holy Spirit" sweeps in. Iona has become what it
is - a centre of pilgrimage for 120,000 people a year - through a Spirit-lead
theology of continuing revelation and not by trying to imitate something which
history has left behind. In practice, this has meant finding focus in, for
instance, urban areas of multiple deprivation, with people who are suffering
or marginalised and in protest at nuclear bases. These things matter as much
as having rebuilt Iona's ancient Abbey.
an south-facing window of Iona Abbey, a small lamp perpetually shines down
towards Ireland and out over the great Atlantic. Iona is rooted equally in the
brokenness and the joy of our times. This is what makes the lamp a light in
being its business advisor for five years, I never fully joined the Iona
Community because I could not accept, without disqualifying qualification, the
apparent imperialism of assertions like, "Christ is Lord." I also
believe that the Christian churches do not have a monopoly on the movement of
the Spirit, and that we can see from fragments of our own pre-Christian
traditions that we too once had practices very much like those in other
cultures where shamanism, or non-clericised spirituality, features. Thus, as
we white people around the world reach out for indigenous shamanic insight to
help address the pressing issues of our times, why not seek it too in our own
native roots? We might even find something worth offering back to the
indigenous American, African and Aboriginal cultures which so inspire us. This
could turn what can be an unsightly and hungry grasping into a mutual
celebratory sharing. Perhaps, unwittingly, the Iona Community shows how to do
this: draw what you can from historical, archaeological and folklore sources,
but don't be limited by them or exaggerate their significance. Seek too the
wind of the Spirit.
here we are. We're in Killarney, May 1994, and it's the International Transpersonal
Association's conference on the theme: "Towards Earth Community: Ecology,
Native Wisdom and Spirituality." 1,600 people are here; a majority
American; many excited by such Celtic relics as Stones.
is my partner for a holotropic breath workshop with two special teachers,
Christina and Stanislav Grof. My mind's multidimensionally blown by meeting
all these people who have shaped my life over the past twenty years through
transpersonal psychology - approaches to psychology which include the
come back to the conference shortly, but for now let's jump to the last night.
Vasunda's heard there's a faerie Stone Circle near Killarney town. She wants
to go there, maybe talk with faeries. Why should I discourage her just because
I'm a bit blase about Stones? - Sure, I'll come too. - Lets grab a cab.
to the faeries is something I've ambivalently been coming to terms with over
the past year. It happened first in March '93 in the Australian rainforest.
I'd been with John Seed and his rainforest action people, running a workshop
on "Organisational Finance and Management as a Far-out Spiritual
Experience," when I met the Rotting Tree Faerie in the Nightcap National
Park. Thankfully, I was able to make the experience respectable by writing it
up in a respected periodical.2
It had been a visionary experience which gave insight into the process of rot
and soil formation in a rainforest ecosystem. Faerie stories are great for
teaching children; they can work for adults too, not least because their power
lots of people at Killarney were talking about faeries. It had felt very
natural, for instance, lying under an old lime tree with Amy the night of the
closing concert of the conference. She was talking with a faerie, feeling far,
far out of her body, speaking wonderful realities. Jung might have connected
such experiences with archetypal processes in the unconscious. I'm happy
enough with thinking that, just so long as it doesn't destroy the magic. I'm
also very taken in these respects by the work of theologian Walter Wink who
talks about "unmasking the principalities and the powers."3
He says that "Every species and thing has its angel;" meaning the
inner spiritual realities of material and social forms. These are all around
to be seen, if we're open to them. Thus Francis Thompson:
The angels keep their ancient places;-
Turn but a stone and start a wing!
'Tis ye, 'tis your estranged faces,
That miss the many-splendoured thing.4
Vasunda and I get out of our cab and set off across a field. We eventually find
the ring of Stones. She enters a deeply meditative state. I just wander around
getting midge-eaten. She gives the faeries a gift, and asks for something for
her son. They give her, metaphorically of course, a silver jawbone. She asks
what it means. They say it is the gift of eloquence.
back to Killarney I tell her how, traditionally in Celtic culture, eloquence was
considered the greatest gift. And I mean eloquence,
as distinct from the mere cleverness often implied by our use of the word
"articulate." Eloquence, as
rooted in the deep poetry of all life. And poetry. What is poetry but that
pertaining to the Latin "poesis," from the Greek "poiesis,"
meaning simply but profoundly, "to make!" To be gifted with words, to
know the significance of of "magic words," of a "spell" ...
can be literally to reweave the world, or, as in Kenneth White's
to see it being rewoven through and with us by the be-ing of nature. Such poesis
is the cutting edge of reality; part of that creative
"sacrament of the present moment" where the mythological framework of
reality in which our lives paint their meaning becomes flesh from spirit.
"In the beginning was the Word," commences St John's gospel.
of course, poesis is the music and all the other ways of seeing and being which
the art of life offers. Starhawk,
Adrienne Rich and many of the other feminist prophets of our time take this for
"Truth is the dare,"7
says Starhawk, beautifully paralleling from a "pagan" perspective in
her book, "Truth or Dare," what Wink draws from Christianity. Truth is
both the goal and the source of courage by which we dare.
writing this essay now, my wrestling is with how far to tell some experiential
truths. Bearing witness to truth, what the Quaker George Fox called
"speaking truth to power," is perhaps the only way by which we can
step outside consensus reality. This calling to our senses is fundamentally
shamanic, fundamentally pertaining to a prophetic theology. I like using the
word, "theology." It's a sort of intellectually-based version of
"spirituality." It's good for bridging new ways of seeing with those
recognised by more traditional cultural frameworks like religion. But
personally, I define theology not as most religions. For me it is concern with the
meanings of Life in all its passions. Whether this includes "God"
depends on what you mean by God.
live in an era of wobbly epistemology - of unsure foundations to what we think
we know. Old paradigms in technology, science and economics agressively strive
to hold on as they grow cancerously or grey into self-strangulated corpses. We
might laugh, were it not that so much social and ecological suffering is
perpetrated. Recent centuries of modernism have not been free of myth. The
presumption of objective scientific detatchment has itself been myth and is fast
revealing its dysfunctionality.
listening now must be for new revelation from the deep poesis. We need a
conscious opening up to remythologisation, but this in an iterative sense to
allow direction to change and find the best "feel." It must be
grounded in that Zen acceptance of nature as it is, as we find it, but also
empassioned and redeemed by that very human Spirit of love which is Holy - which
is pertaining to "wholeness," as the Old Germanic origin of the word
"holy" means. This creatively inspired re-making and re-telling of
story and vision is central to the re-enchantment of life. As Ralph Metzner said
at the conference, "Stories tell us about our past; visions tell us about
a laugh meeting Ralph Metzner who had organised the conference for us! The Irish
press joked about his greying pigtail. Had it been otherwise they'd have talked
of sell-out ... Metzner of that original Harvard paradigm-busting-until-busted
Alpert-Metzner-Leary triune: king, priest and holy fool.
let's jump back to the end of the conference. We're off down to the Beara
peninsula in South-West Ireland. I'm with Amy's friends, Sarah and Jerry. We're
going to meet Mike Collard, who grows trees and says that he and we are of the
faeries. Last year there were hardly any butterflies in Ireland, or Scotland and
England, and he was sad because "nature was not shining." This year
there are lots of butterflies - many cuckoos too, he adds; - maybe nature knows
that that green thinking is starting to win, to be heard. That's why the Earth
has shone this spring. A nice, simplistic?, philosophy from this mild onetime
Oxford philosopher, who doubtless delighted to hear news from the Dublin
constituency a week later of the election of Ireland's first Green Member of the
are the faeries," Mike says, "and we have waited underground for
thousands of years. Now the destruction has culminated and it is time for the
re-emergence of the "aes sidhe" -the "Tuatha De Dannan," -
the "people of the mother goddess."
De Dannan were the orgiginal god-and-human-like inhabitants of Ireland.
According to the old Irish Book of Invasions, they were driven under the Earth
when invading "Milesians" arrived. There they became the "aes
sidhe," the faeries. In Gaelic, the word "sidhe" means both
faerie and "peace." The faeries are the people of peace.8
believe it was the Milesians who destroyed the ancient forests of Ireland,"
Mike continues. "We, the faerie folk, had to stay hidden, because if we had
fought we'd just have become like them. So we waited, long we waited, and now
we're starting to re-emerge."
Jerry, Sarah and I smile at the incongruous congruity of pictures of Christ and
the Blessed Virgin in the home of this devoutly Roman Catholic, devoutly pagan
is Christ?" I ask him and his wife, Cathy.
Krishna if you like," one of them replies.
head far out west the next day, journeying to meet up with Dierdie McCartin and
Charlie Rees of the Allihies Folklore Centre. They see that for communities to
remythologise, to re-make their story of who they are and what they value, the
children first need to learn their existing mythology. Folklore was the most
politically powerful thing Dierdre could think of doing to crown a distinguished
feminist career in Irish TV and academia. This she had abandoned, after making a
film about Mary Daly's visit to Dublin. "I mean, how can you stay on after
such a self-proclaimed "positively revolting hag" has caricatured the
modern university as "progressively higher degrees of deterioration of
the Folklore Centre Jerry and Sarah are very taken with pictures and stories of
the "Hag of Beara" - a rock said to be an empowered woman turned to
stone; a goddess. We set off to visit "her." On the way, we get a
strange look from a wild old man. An angry fire blazes in his eyes. - Spooky,
says Jerry. We pass him twice. The second time, I wave in propriation. His hand
lifts; grudged reciprocation.
takes a long time to find the Hag. We were looking for something big. But she
turns out to be only four or five feet high. Jerry and I chuckle at such
apparent Irish hype. Not so, Sarah. I brag that in Scotland we wouldn't call
THAT a Hag! Jerry asks me to get out of the way so he can photograph Sarah
beside it, "the two hags!" he quips. Sarah leaves a coin amongst
others placed in folds of the rock by the superstitious, or the knowing. I'm
feeling restless; time to go. We walk away. Suddenly, Jerry's camera kind of
jumps out of his breast pocket. It strikes a rock. Springs open.
he's really spooked. An Hitchcockesque image of the wild man counterpoints the
Hag in his mind. The camera and most of the film are OK. But the "two
hags" picture is exposed; gone.
shuffle away, me debating in myself whether to feel genuine awe at this ...
little Hag, or just to have a laugh on Jerry at such timely synchronicity. Back
in Allihies, Dierdrie's in no doubt. This is folklore in the making! And she's
full of stories of people's encounters with the Hag. Seemingly, in olden times,
the Hag of Beara was famous all over Ireland, even into Scotland. She was quite
someone, female and part-male too, the little Hag; the Hag who HOLDS this, the
far South-West corner of Ireland.
Stones. Like tourists to Callanish, Jerry and Sarah are talking again about
wanting to visit Stones. I suppose they've never seen Stones before. We'll stop
at the next site.
sleep rough around a fire on Kilcatherine Point, close to where the Hag resides.
By the time we finish making music and telling stories, the sun has nearly moved
round to the east. We had watched it set in the west. For the last few minutes a
golden corridor of light had stretched across the Atlantic. And up, staircasing
over Kerry hills on the horizon, and further up, through the sun itself, beyond.
The sky filled with that molten metal for which those who cannot see it all
around daily break their lives and nature.
course, we had come predisposed to feel close to nature. Round the driftwood
fire we laughed at Jerry's story of a church group back home in the States which
always doused the campsite with insecticide before camping out.
for two or three hours. Then wake up, all covered with midges. Midges drive you
mad. Our skin is itching, blotched and puffy. Even hiding into the sleeping bag
doesn't work; you have to breathe. Jerry runs to get some "bug"
repellant. I can't help laughing at him, at ourselves, after last night's
storying. The spray is "natural." Its cinnamon, peppermint and lemon
oil works for only a short time. Through my mind run the merits of chemical
factories which produce ICI Flypel, Jungle Formula, and other un-right-on
compounds that really do work. We rekindle the fire. Lying in the smoke works.
None of us have slept much. Sleeping out is, sometimes, what it's cracked up to
set off again. Swim in the sea by some caves which make a roaring sound like a
giant's gasp. Press on. Perchance we come, mid-afternoon, the first day of June,
to a sign at Ardgroom. "Stone Circle - this way."
card they had in the Folklore Centre comes to mind. The Hippies turn up at The
Stones in a flowerpower painted old VW bus. They dance, hug and chant with the
Stones, celebrating the elements as the weather keeps changing. Finally, they're
deeply attuned in meditation, when a flash of lightening zaps them to charcoal.
Like our midges, nature also has her sting. If we forget that; if we Bambify
nature, we lose balanced understanding.
at least, that would be the received wisdom.
here we are. We're walking a mile up a farm lane to the Stones. Let's capitalise
it all just for a laugh: THE STONES. The beauty enchants us. So many flowers. So
much lichen, and ferns and birdsong and butterflies. Nature this beautiful does
change consciousness. Such recognition is the essence of deep ecology, but the
experience is robbed from most people today who have rare access to real nature.
Read 19th century observers on the desecration of nature in the wake of such
land "improvement" as sheep farming. Take, for instance, Dr John
Mackenzie's memoirs (1803 - 1886) of Loch Maree in Scotland:
It was in as lovely a spot in a wild Highland glen as any lover of
country scenery could desire to see. I mean then,
for then no sheep vermin had got hoof in it, as ere long they did. Then only
cattle ever bit a blade of grass there, and the consequence was that the braes
and wooded hillocks were a perfect jungle of every kind of loveable shrubs and
wild flowers, especially orchids - some, of the Epipactis tribe, being
everywhere a lovely drug that I often got many thanks for sending to botanic
gardens in the South. The milk cows never troubled their heads to force through
this flowery jungle, laced up with heaps of honeysuckle and crowds of seedling
hazel and other native trees and shrubs. Till my Father's death in 1826, no
sheep's hoof defiled the glen unless passing through it to the larder. But very
soon after, an offer of a trifling rent for sheep pasturing let these horrid
brutes into the glen, and every wild flower, and every young seedling bush or
tree was eaten into the ground, so that an offer of a thousand pounds would not
find one of my loved wild flowers or a young shrub from seed - nothing but a
bare lot of poles, whose very leaves were all eaten up the instant one of them
appeared. Those who remembered the wooded glen of 1826, and now looked at it,
would never believe it was the same place - unless seen from a distance, for the
sheep could not eat up the beautiful wild hills.9
Or take the Loch Katrine of Sir Walter Scott, whose description brought the
first tourists flocking from the south:
So wondrous wild, the whole might seem
The scenery of a fairy dream...10
too the old Chinese nature mystics like Wang Wei.11
Or Celtic shamanic poets from the same era, especially the seventh century Irish
Suibhne, who in his love affair with nature after going "mad" in
battle was forever being "ravished" by the Earth's sweetness.12
Ask how far modern consumerism is but a perverse retail therapy, driven by
advertising to produce a consensus reality which pretends to answer such loss of
the Eden where only our souls know we belong. Ask too how far quantity of
consumption could be substituted by right relationship with nature, community
and the creative spirit, thereby enhancing quality of life while shrinking
material GNP to sustainable levels. And why should we not level, as a very political
demand, policies for national "development" focussed around nothing
less than the affirmation of life in its discovery of love?
pace slackens. Conversation lulls. We act, perhaps, "as if" we are
starting to walk on holy ground.
sea spreads out and fills our vision below. Above are the vertebral hills of the
Beara peninsula. We see the Stones now. A small circle of about seven, rooted in
rocky plateau, mediating between this ocean and that mountain range. Higher up
on the moor is smoke. A farmer burns heather and gorse. Dimly I am aware of him,
but do not notice his collie dog which Jerry later said was also there.
on the moor! As boys on Lewis we used to light the heather to see how many
hillsides could be set ablaze with just one match. My record was three. We grew
up in nature, but mostly had little deep feeling for it; at least, not that we
were then aware of. The old ways were fast going back in the 'sixties. Only
vague nostalgia suggested any residual value in place or culture. We were not
taught our history in school. It was not in the curriculum. We would leave home
once "educated" enough. Leave the heavy religion; maybe not leave the
heavy drink. Seek sex without everyone talking. Leave Lewis to the landlords
with their ridiculous southern "sporting" ways. Our aim was to
"get out and get on in the world."
Moorland served only as a seat for sheep subsidy to keep the old men
going. Certainly, no need for Stones. Little for poetry either. And had we not,
after all, been conveniently told by the coldly religious in primary school that
folk dancing "was a sin," because Salome had danced with the head of
John the Baptist? But as the new music of the later 'sixties swept in, it didn't
suit us to apply that injunction to the disco. Happily now it's all changed
again, as the combination of rock and rediscoverd folk music join hands in a
powerful cultural and politicised renaissance.
there's a fire burning on the moor up above. And at the Killarney conference
David Whyte had read Yeats' shamanic poem about "fire in the head."
I learned more about reading poetry from this Englishman that night than
in all my formal education. What struck me was the way he would keep repeating
important phrases. He read this from Yeats:
I went out to the hazel wood,
Because a fire was in my head,
And cut and peeled a hazel wand,
And hooked a berry to a thread;
And when white moths were on the wing,
And moth-like stars were flickering out,
I dropped the berry in a stream
and caught a little silver trout.
yes! So Yeats had given it a name. "Fire in the head!" Recognition of
his recognition rocked me. Galeforce. Gaelforce. Wind now storming fire in head.
me explain. Let's move back awhile to the conference opening ceremony, we'll
return to these Stones in a minute.
Imelda Smith, an Irish nun, was leading us in the welcoming ritual. She called
for the voices of the land and peoples from all four corners of the world to
enter the spirit of the conference. We sung responses. My head ignited.
through my mind had been the presentation I was to give later in the week. Its
form had not yet crystallised: "Community, Spirit, Place: the Revival of
the Celtic Shaman" -was the title to which my silver trout had to rise. But
I knew I wanted to talk about activism - about showing signs of being alive -
"liberation," in Guttierez's sense of "to give life,"13 and what Walter Wink
means by naming the powers and unmasking them, so that they can be engaged.
was wanting to connect ecological with social justice. Wanting to talk about
Scotland today, where 0.08% of the people own 80% of the private land and 20% of
our five million population live below the European decency threshold, many in
urban Soweto segregation ghettos of multiple deprivation. A Scotland where the
last wolf was shot in 1743, just 3 years before the Battle of Culloden sealed
the tomb of the old clan kinship system. A Scotland where many of us have grown
up in nature, estranged from it, not least because it and we are controlled by
landowning "lairds" based in Switzerland or Dubai or the States or
England. And a Scotland where attitudes were too often afflicted from a pulpit
which, perhaps as a transcendent reponse to such terrible loss of the immanent,
cast nature as more accursed than blessed.
here I was, wanting to ask some of these 1,600 people, mostly American, whether
they were ready to unpack their history. To re-read history; re-membering,
re-visioning, re-claiming the people that they are; learning how, for instance,
half a million Scots had been forced off the land in the nineteenth century
Highland Clearances to make way for commercial sheep farms and playboy sporting
estates. Seeing how many who had gone to the New World, to Australia and
elsewhere, perpetuated and reperpetuated their oppression against other native
in the conference I was to learn a name with which to name the Powers,
"lateral violence." Violence, that breaks out sideways when it cannot
be channelled vertically. Violence against others who are oppressed, because the
real oppressor is invisible or unreachable.
to this account of the Highland Clearances, written down around 1928, from
Catherine MacPhee of North Uist in the Hebrides. "MacPhee" is a very
ancient Scottish name meaning, "of the faeries." Interesting. Listen,
then, to this faerie woman speak. No tinselled escapism here!
Many a thing have I seen in my own day and generation.
Many a thing, O Mary Mother of the black sorrow! I have seen the
townships swept, and the big holdings being made of them, the people being
driven out of the countryside to the streets of Glasgow and to the wilds of
Canada, such of them as did not die of hunger and plague and smallpox while
going across the ocean. I have seen the women putting the children in the carts
which were being sent from Benbecula and the Iochdar to Loch Boisdale, while
their husbands lay bound in the pen and were weeping beside them, without power
to give them a helping hand, though the women themselves were crying aloud and
their little children wailing like to break their hearts.
I have seen the big strong men, the champions of the countryside, the
stalwarts of the world, being bound on Loch Boisdale quay and cast into the ship
as would be done to a batch of horses or cattle in the boat, the bailiffs and
the ground‑officers and the constables and the policemen gathered behind
them in pursuit of them. The God of
life and He only knows all the loathsome work of men on that day.14
want to reflect a bit on nationality and ethnicity in this section. It will be
speculative. Ground I've not charted before, so I'm worried about causing
offense or seeming naive. But this is what an "essay" is for - to assay
question. What is it like to find that your forbears have been mainly on the
oppressor side of history? Or that your nation is in this role today? Is there
anything they, we, can learn from, say, the parent in therapy coming to terms
with having abused a child?
question. What of the rootless and the deracinated? There's another word not in
most dictionaries, but needing useage because it's a good one. It's French,
meaning, "to have been uprooted." It fits so many people today:
deracination through war, mobility, economic dislocation, etc.. Deracination is
the first step in becoming rootless. Is it reversible? Can we redefine
"belongingness" as being, I'd suggest,
willingness to cherish, and be cherished, by a place and its peoples? The
Celtic tradition has precedence for this. Celtic community (inasmuch as it is
unwise to generalise about the past) was sometimes more a bonding of spirit than
of lineage, as indicated by a Gaelic proverb that "the bonds of milk
(nurture) are stronger than those of blood."
the cultural position of England. I am part-English, and find it much harder to
"own" that part than is the case with my Scottish antecedents. Mike
Collard had been saying he felt like he came from an endangered peoples, the
indigenous English countryfolk: the ones who understood ecology and community,
who had tried to preserve England as a "green and pleasant land"
against the tide of enclosure and industrialisation. This, a Yeomanic
Englishness, a substantially Celtic Englishness, largely destroyed in Roman
and Norman times ... before even Mrs Thatcher, Francis Bacon or the piratical
too those young Germans who come to the Celtic edge in growing numbers to learn
our culture and especially music. They say they cannot sing their own folksongs
because of the way they were abused by the Nazis. Celtic culture once covered
much of Europe. It has many elements of being a common global heritage as well
as being place-specific. Pushed back by Roman and other influences, it clings on
to Europe's very edge. But as a conference speaker had said, "When the
centre collapses the periphery becomes central." Yet, consider how
dis-heart-ening it must be for these sensitive German people to feel
uncomfortable with their own more immediate taproots! I tell them that, in a
less recognised and more easily resolved way, we had it too. Our dance music was
squashed with the 1747 Act of Proscription, the Act of cultural genocide
following defeat at Culloden. Tartan and the kilt was made illegal except in the
army. Dance tunes were turned into military marches, rhythm rapped by sharp
snare drums. Pipe bands became an instrument of war, wielded to frighten other
native peoples into respect for the British Empire. But now, we are reclaiming
what is ours from the military; dancing again with swing; playing with no
constraint on unregimented improvisation. Can Germany, that which should be a
beloved Germany, can it possibly do likewise?
at this conference, there's hardly any English, a few Germans, but lots of
Americans. So I'm wondering if I can weave into my presentation something about
our "Anglo-American" "special relationship;" a different
understanding of cultural history, especially addressing those Americans who
maybe feel bad about their country's geopolitical antics. You know, really the
only difference between them and me is that my great great great grandfather
compromised at home. He stayed in the Highlands and became home farm manager to
Lord and Lady Stafford of Dunrobin Castle, Sutherland: quite the most notorious
of the Clearance landlords. The great-several-times-over grandparents of many of
the Americans here were the ones who left, but became the oppressor of the black
man, the red woman, the hispanic, and the poor of their own kind in the land of
the brave and the free.
seems paradoxical that Ireland should have marked my first meeting with native
Americans. Looking across the Atlantic from Lewis I have often wondered about
them. in 1851 the Scottish land rights campaigner John Murdoch wrote in The
Highlander of parallels between our respective cultures saying, "... the
dying wail of the cheated redman of the woods rings in our ears across the
The 1886 Crofting Act gave peasant smallholders security of tenure, but
still under the landlord's "feudal superiorship" and the landlord's
have kept the vast bulk of the land and resources. In this respect, our crofting
communities today have a status very similar to that of "Indian"
am touched as the indigenous American activist, Winona La Duke, explains to the
little girl with her that "Alastair is a kind of white Indian.... There are
white Indians in places like Ireland and Scotland, but you just don't hear very
much about them...." But I also wonder why we can't all be white Indians?
What makes one "indigenous." - Connectedness with folk and place, I
suppose. Vasunda, Eric and Bron all talk about the importance of bioregionalism
to re-create this. But first we need to break cultural karma. We need to get
past those patterns of abuse that prevent identification with the nature of a
place, which force perpetual restlessness.
great Hindu-Catholic theologian, Raimon Panikkar, said at a conference we had in
Glasgow in 1989 - "No Life Without Roots" - that "only
forgiveness breaks the law of karma." That's good: forgiveness - which is
acceptance - of self and others. But first we have to recognise, to name, to
re-member that which needs forgiving; that which is in need of, salvation. The
very word "salvation" means "to heal." We have to see
through maya to shift karma and iteratively break karma to see through maya.
Thus, a question I want to put is whether we actually need a cultural
a transatlantic cultural psychotherapy; a movement towards healing wounds of the
broken and to this day laird-ridden disempowered communities left behind in the
Old World, and also those of the sometimes brash, breaking, un-communities of
the New World.
heard a lot from Mrs Thatcher and Mr Reagan about the transatlantic
"special relationship." Some relationship! One of worshipping the
Golden Calf and Moloch - that fire-filled Old Testament stone god into which the
children were burnt alive to procure riches.
relationship! One of Cruise missiles and the Trident nuclear submarine programme.
As I write, seventy nuclear missiles for Trident are on their way to Scotland
from the States. Our Secretary for Defence describes the first test firing as,
"a visible demonstration of the effectiveness of the UK's independent
strategic nuclear deterrent."18
A more honest description might be velvet thuggery.
know, when I think of America I feel a bit like the Kogi in Alan Ereira's film
about the "elder brother's warning" from the "heart of the
world." Go into many a Highland croft house at Christmas; Irish homes too,
and see from the cards where the extended family now resides. To us, you are our
younger sisters and brothers who, wrenched from us, went or were sent out into
that new world and repeated there what had been done to you.
because you are of us that we have high expectations and hopes of you. Why, too,
your eternal return resides here. This is why, deeply, underneath all our
anti-Yankee anger, even in spite of Vietnam and Latin America and nuclear tests
on Pacific Islanders and because of Alice Walker and Noam Chomski and Walt
Whitman and Adrienne Rich ... we care about you.
need mutually to heal, to stop crushing ourselves and others and the planet. A
transatlantic cultural psychotherapy? Perhaps.
may God bless America.
(because I'm getting a little confused even if you're not) that we're at the
opening ceremony of the International Transpersonal Association's conference in
fire in my head sparked by Imelda's ritual is not unique. I have known it a
little previously. I remember October 1991. We were on the Inner Hebridean Isle
of Eigg. I was there with Tom Forsyth. His name is another of those old Scots
ones meaning, "man of the faeries."
Also, Bob Harris. Harris means in Gaelic, "of the hills." We
were to present, for public approval, the aims of a land restitution trust, the
Isle of Eigg Trust, set up to challenge the right of wealthy individuals to own
what had once been the common land of a whole community and to break these
communities either through ignorance or for the "sport" of it.
was to make the speech. Crossing the island to the village hall was a powerful
experience. It felt as if the voices of the Old People, the folk long passed
over, the transported folk ... their voices, were coming
up from out of the rocks, as if into me. To them I owed the eloquence which
won a degree of community endorsement unprecedented in recent Scottish land
Walker. Black American poet with an Irish/Scot name. Her words speak to what the
three of us knew that night.
While love is unfashionable
let us live
Seeing the world
a complex ball
in small hands;
love our blackest garment.
Let us be poor
in all but truth, and courage
by the old
Let us be intimate with
of the undead.
old spirits. Intimate with ancestral ghosts. The music of the undead... like the
great Scottish fiddler J. Scott Skinner said when praising those musicians who
"still remembered to render their country's music by the light of nature,
maintaining its ruggedness and character, and not making it insipid and genteel."20
While love is dangerous
let us walk bareheaded
beside the Great River.
Let us gather blossoms
in the head again tonight as this ritual unfolds! But this time, huge fire. A
Great River of gleaming silver fire. I'm seated with John Seed's soulfriend,
Heart Phoenix. We're in this huge marquis with five TV screens. My heart mingles
with the Great River of hers. I get this vision of the Old People of Scotland
entering the conference. Tears are welling up and running down my cheeks.
Usually I can't cry. Now my eyes are streaming.
Old People have come. The ancestral ghosts have arrived. Feel the calibre of
their spirit! Listen to Mary MacPherson, Mairi Mhor nan Oran of Skye, the
greatest late nineteenth century bard of the Clearances:
... It reminded me of many things I had done,
some of which I shall not gather in until the
end of my days -
going to waulkings and weddings in winter,
not with lantern light but with a burning peat;
lively youngsters engaged in music and dancing then,
but that time has gone and the glen is saddened;
the ruins of Andrew's house, overgrown with nettles,
reminded me of when I was young....
with light-hearted young people who have now
been driven away
descendants of native folk who were free of vanity
here we all are. By the Great River. Streams of living water form into a shining
mantle around my shoulders. The
silver jaw opens: "This is the mantle of Scottish history. Share it with
those who come here."
in the head. And next I'm under the ocean. I'm looking at and feeling for the
Atlantic seabed. Daily its habitats are ploughed up with modern fishing
techniques. I have worked with the seabed; seen gentle livelihoods of prawn
creelers and scallop divers destroyed by crude dredging technology running seven
times twenty-four hours a week. The mantle of the ocean's angst rests on me too.
the mountains. The noble hills they want to superquarry, exporting motorway road
aggregate to Europe and even the States. And I'm seeing the empty glens, the
"forests" of the "living dead" - those few dear old Scots
pines, the last remnants of native forest, drawn and quartered to the stocking
pressures of deer and sheep. The trees too have come here, rustling the inside
of my skull to have witness borne on their behalf.
of me asks if this is silly. "Mantle of Scottish history" my ass! But
tears flood my face. They sweep away such, false humility; the fear of rising
when called; the pride that twists humility to avert possible fall and ridicule.
slept poorly the next three nights. The fire would not let go; truly, burning
somewhat. My friends who had also come to the conference, Brendan, Mary Anna,
the two Jo's, Rachael -they probably found me a little strange, distant-like. It
was easier with strangers. No "usual self" to live up to.
at last came, the day of my presentation. Words, images, music and poetry.
Honoured by the help of a black American activist academic, Janis Prior, to
recite Alice Walker's poetry ... poetic because she had just chaired a wonderful
session with Alice Walker's daughter at her college the previous week. And Ann
O'Conner from Ireland and Steve Blamires of Scotland to read Celtic material.
cultural psychotherapy. Earlier in the day I had attended a presentation by Jane
She was now at mine, hearing something already being re-shaped by what she had
said. Get this! Jane works to heal communities, mostly indigenous American,
whose structures have broken down so much that alcoholism and other addictions
are just taken for granted. She said that people usually only ask her in when
"generational trauma" becomes so pronounced that the children start
killing themselves. She draws out their humour, compassion and stubbornness,
hoping to overcome learned helplessness, observing that "seventy percent of
the people I work with found solace in nature."
was Jane who had brought up the "lateral violence" concept.
"Children," she said, "are the canaries of our planet, of our
communities." And I find myself thinking of some of our Scottish Highland
communities where even adolescent children can be well established on the path
to alcoholism. I think how difficult it sometimes is to have a coherent public
meeting in some such communities where there are folk, genuine folk, who can
speak only when they have "a good dram on them."
Heavy drink and nicotine toggling with heavy religion. Heavy
meek are getting ready," says next week's page in the Peace Diary. They
would be if they weren't so meek.
words reverberate: "Children are the canaries of our communities." The
very night I return from Ireland, a phone call comes through about one of our
traumatised Highland communities. An adolescent boy has hanged himself while at
play. It happened just an hour ago. Purely accidental tragedy. And pure
coincidence, but it felt eerily prophetic.
friend, Alastair Hulbert, writes to me about his interactions with the Forward
Planning Unit - the think-tank of the President of the European Union. They've
been discussing ecological economics, and theology - Jacques Delors is a devout
Catholic. Alastair has been calling for a "theology of insistence;" a
visionary and proactive counterpoint to the more familiar theologies of
resistance. Yes. And in this, like Macdairmid, "I am concerned for the
blossom." Concerned for the children ...
hear Ben Shianta:
Many are the poor bothies destroyed on every side,
Each one only a grey outline on the green grass;
And many a roofless dwelling
A heap of stones beside the bubbling spring;
Where the fire and the children were,
There the rushes grow highest.24
the conference is over now. And here's me, and Jerry Cook, and Sarah Hinkley.
Remember? We're at Ardgroom on the Beara peninsula in South-West Ireland. We're
walking up this incredibly beautiful lane to The Stones.
now. Missing absent friends, my children too - they'd love it here. Sarah says
Amy's with us, present through her at times. Wishing I had been more fully
present with people at the conference instead of feeling, as I did after the
presentation, somewhat poised at the keystane of overexposure and loneliness.
here's me and Sarah and Jerry. Sarah's inside the Stone circle now. Jerry's
standing back. And it is holy ground we are walking on. At a Clearance village
on Skye three weeks ago I had taken off my boots and walked barefoot for three
miles, until the Golden Eagles came. Holy pilgrimage. Promised land. Coming up
here, too, I should have taken off my shoes from off my feet.
feel moved to kneel and do so, just outside the magical ring. Eyes closed. Can
still kind of vividly see Sarah praying inside. Reopen my eyes. It was almost as
if I had been seeing her through the eyelids. Visual imagery unusually good
today. And nature is so present! So wholly present in these clumps of rushes;
rushes with foxglove growing through: and shamrock, the little shamrock,
trifoliate spiral whirl, tripartite goddess, holy trinity, heart of the lotus
shamrock of a holy crucified Ireland.
of David Whyte's style in my mind. Differing poetic strands mingle, a common
Where the fire and the children were. Lively youngsters engaged in music
and dancing then. Fire in the head. Not with lantern light but with a burning
peat. Fire on the moor. The Children, concerned with the blossom. Engaged in
music and dancing then. Canaries of our planet.
Where the fire and the children were THERE There there the rushes grow
where the fire and the children were There the rushes grow highest by the ruins
of Andrew's house, overgrown with nettles.
Where the fire and the children are ... there. Let us be intimate with
ancestral ghosts and HERE COMES the Fire in the Head the music of the undead
(syncopated triplets of Highland dance) and WE SHALL GATHER BLOSSOMS under fire.
Shamrock leaf. Triple goddess. Holy Trinity. Jewel, in the Heart of the
Lotus. And we are, in spite of everything, perfected beings in the course of
eyes shut on the Stones again. Still kneeling in this place where rushes grow
highest. Now, prostrate. Arms outstretched. Body pressing grassy ground.
I am asleep.
Jerry said later, "It was almost immediate. Really strange. I could tell by
your breathing. You'd fallen immediately asleep."
heard the previous day a tale from Charlie about the "hungry grass,"
magic grass that enshrouds with a mantle of instant sleep, leaving the sleeper
afterwards, "hungry." - Hungry for what? - Food, they'd say. - What
sort of food? - We don't know.
mean," Jerry continues, "I know we were all short of sleep from the
midges. But after all that spooking with the Hag yesterday I was almost
wondering if you'd found some hungry grass!"
I was dimly aware of slipping into a deep pool of sleep. As I closed my eyes an
afterimage of the Stones endured. But it was also as if I was seeing
underground, down into the mantle of the Earth.
seemed as if all the Stones were connected: as if they were fixed shoots from a
common root; a grounding in some sort of magmatic flux circumferencing the
unusual was happening. But by now I was too nearly asleep to question it. Again,
the silver jaw opened. Words rang in the last glimmer of consciousness.
is the deep energy of the Earth. These stones connect it. That is what such
places are about."
I am inside the stone circle where Sarah had been. There is no sign of her or
the ground around each stone, golden fire is blazing. Flames several feet high
flare out and trail off into smoke.
the Narnia chronicles, C.S. Lewis refers to the deep magic of the Earth, put in
place when time began. But I'm puzzled; seeking even now a more mundane
step out of the circle. What might be behind the stones?
Ahh! Found it! A shepherd is there. A farmer, collie dog beside him. So that's
it. He's burning off gorse - the fool. Doesn't he realise fire will crack the
man is large bodied, maybe thirtyish. Perfectly ordinary looking, except that he
has a strangely perfect complexion. His face positively shines. He sits with his
back against one of the stones.
walk in front. Stand and stare. He seems not to see me. Flames and smoke billow
all around. He is totally tranquil. Utterly unperturbed.
wake up. Only a few minutes have passed.
had this man of the shining countenance been? Was he really so oblivious to the
fire? Could he could see it no more than he could see me?
was the fire just normal to him? Was it so natural, so inevitable and so
belonging here that perhaps even he was from the flames? Unconsumed. Burning
bush. Holy ground.
think of Mike Collard. The Tutha De Dannan as the original faerie folk. Their
re-emergence. And shining countenance, countenance, countenance.
there an apocryphal name somewhere? Maybe
a poet's idiom, or Evans-Wentz? I can't source it. But suddenly memory connects
with heart. Recognition - real or imagined - wells-up. Re-cognition. Tears of
account of their countenance the Tutha De Dannan were known as, "the
"Chunnaic sinn bristeadh na faire, is neoil na trailealachd air
chall an latha sheas MacCalium laimh rinn."
"We saw the dawn break, and the clouds of thraldom flee away, the
day MacCallum stood beside us, at the Faerie Bridge."
- Mairi Mhor nan Oran, Bard
1. Griffin, S., a Chorus of Stones: The Private Life of War, The Womens' Press, London, 1992, cover quotation.
2. McIntosh, A., Rainforests and High Finance: A Faerie Tale and Open Letter to Alice Walker, World Rainforest Report, 26, 1993, Australia, pp. 18 - 20.
3. Wink, W. Naming the Powers: The Language of Power in the New Testament (1984), Unmasking the Powers: The Invisible Forces That Determine Human Existence (1986), Engaging the Powers: Discernment and Resistance in a World of Domination (1992), all from Fortress Press, Philadelphia.
4. Cited in Wink, W. Unmasking the Powers, op. cit., p. 170.
5. White, K., Elements of Geopoetics, Edinburgh Review, 88, Edinburgh, 1992, pp. 163 - 168. White is one of the most important contemporary Scottish environmental poets; an exemplar of Celtic zen. He holds the chair in 20th century poetics at the Sorbonne but, ashamedly, is poorly known at home. Geopoetics is a "higher unity" of person and place.
6. See, for instance, Rich, A., What is Found There: Notebooks on Poetry and Politics, W. W. Norton & Co., London, 1993.
7. Starhawk, Truth or Dare: Encounters with Power, Authority and Mystery, HarperSanFransisco, 1990, p. 27.
8. A good sourcebook is Ellis, P. Berresford, Dictionary of Celtic Mythology, Constable, London, 1992. Ellis comments on Irish "similarities with the invasion myths of the Indian Rig Veda (which) demonstrates a closeness to the Indo-European root of Celtic culture" (p. 129).
9. Shaw, C. Byam, Pigeon Holes of Memory: The life and times of Dr John Mackenzie, edited from his manuscript memoirs, Constable, London, 1988, pp. 22 - 23. I am grateful to Ronnie Black of the Department of Celtic, Edinburgh University. He drew my attention to this piece when I asked him for old examples of reliable documentation indicative of people being aware of feeling loss over ecological degradation. A typical contemporary expression of such loss and demand for political action to control landlords who only care about maximising the numbers of stags to shoot is Watson, J. & Nicoll, R., Deer Green Place: what price conservation in Glenfeshie ... Cairngorms up for sale, Scotland on Sunday, Edinburgh, 12 June 1994, p. 10.
11. Wang Wei, Poems, trans. G. W. Robinson, Penguin Classics, 1973.
12. Heaney, S. (trans.), Sweeney Astray, faber and faber, London, 1983. See also a fine selection of Celtic nature poetry, including extracts from Suibhne Geilt (Crazy Sweeney) in Jackson, K. H. (ed.), A Celtic Miscellany, Penguin Classics, London, 1951.
13. Gutierrez, G., A Theology of Liberation, SCM Press, London, revised edition 1988, p. xxxvii.
14. From Carmichael, cited in McIntosh, A., Wightman, A. & Morgan, D., Reclaiming the Scottish Highlands: Clearance, Conflict and Crofting, The Ecologist, 24;2, March/April 1994, pp. 64 - 70. (We wrote this article to summarise, especially for overseas readers, Highland history as part of the wider history of enclosure of the commons, with special focus on the contemporary socio-ecological effects of landlordism and efforts being made by crofting (smallholding) communities to re-empower themselves and procure land restitution. A much longer piece, which includes an analysis of the contemporary psychospiritual dynamics of the Highland Clearances, is at press, to be published in French and English in 1995 by Interculture, Montreal as "The Scottish Highlands in Colonial Perspective.")
15. See Fuller, F., Barbarians and Empire, The CoEvolution Quarterly (now Whole Earth Review), Summer 1983, pp. 14 - 26.
16. Murdoch, J. cited in Hunter, J. (ed.), For the People's Cause: From the Writings of John Murdoch, HMSO, Edinburgh, 1986.
17. I must thank Kathy Galloway of the Iona Community for birthing this term, and similarly Maxwell MacLeod for coming up with "retail therapy" - both in discussions where we were wrestling to find adequate vocabulary.
18. Brown, P., Protest delays Trident test, Guardian Weekly, 150;23, 5th June 1994, p. 8.
19. McIntosh, A., "A collector's item" or community ownership - the Isle of Eigg debate, Edinburgh Review, 88, 1992, pp. 158 - 162.
20. Skinner, J. S., A Guide to Bowing, c.1900, cited in Hardie, A., The Caledonian Companion, Hardie Press, Edinburgh, 1992, p. 25.
21. Walker, A., While Love Is Unfashionable, Revolutionary Petunias, Womens Press, London, 1988, p. 68.
22. Cited in MacLean, M. (ed.), As an Fhearann: From the Land, Mainstream, Edinburgh, 1986, p. 62. For combination of texts with a great many pictures, this commemorative publication for the 1886 Crofting Act must be the most useful work available for getting a good feel for the Highland situation. The most authoritative scholarly analysis is Hunter, J., The Making of the Crofting Community, John Donald, Edinburgh, 1976.
23. Middleton-Moz, J., Will to Survive: Affirming the Positive Power of the Human Spirit (1992), Shame and Guilt: Masters of Disguise (1990), Children of Trauma: rediscovering your discarded self (1989), all from Health Communications Inc., Florida.
25. Cited in MacLean, M., (ed.), ibid., p. 25. Mairi Mhor nan Oran was speaking here of the Rev. Donald MacCallum, land rights activist: "The land is our birthright, even as the air, the light of the sun and the water belong to us as our birthright (ibid.)." The parallels between 19th century Highland land activism and 20th century Latin American liberation theology are presented by Meek, D. E., "The Land Question Answered from the Bible"; The Land Issue and the Development of a Highland Theology of Liberation, Scottish Geographical Magazine, 103;2, 1987, pp. 84 -89.
Internet Users Please Note:
The material on this page is original
text as submitted to the publication stated beneath the title. As the editing
process means that some parts may have been cut, altered or corrected after it
left my hands, or I might have made minor subsequent amendments, please specify in citation
“internet version from www.AlastairMcIntosh.com”
as well as citing the place of first publication. Note that author particulars,
including contact address(es) and organisational affiliations may have changed
since first publication.
material is © Alastair McIntosh and/or first publishers. However (and without
prejudice to any legal rights of the original or subsequent publishers), I give
my permission for it to be freely copied for non-commercial educational purposes
provided that due acknowledgement is given. Please advise of any uses that might
particularly interest me. For commercial enquires, please contact original
publishers and/or email me, mail@AlastairMcIntosh.com.
Thanks, folks, and enjoy, enjoy, enjoy!
To RETURN to any sub-index from which you approached this page, click BACK on your web browser. To return to my homepage, click www.AlastairMcIntosh.com.